“20 Books That Became Cult Classics by Accident”

Share this post on:

Books That Became Cult Classics by Accident

The Secret History by Donna Tartt – When College Pretension Became Literary Legend

Did you know that one of literature’s most beloved modern classics started as an undergraduate’s experiment in dark academia? Donna Tartt’s The Secret History was published by Alfred A. Knopf in September 1992, telling the story of a closely knit group of six Classics students at Hampden College, a small, elite liberal arts college in Vermont, through an inverted detective story narrated by one of the six students, Richard Papen, who reflects years later upon the situation that led to the murder of their friend Edmund “Bunny” Corcoran. The book was subject to a bidding war in 1991 and much anticipated before its release, with qualms from a few reviewers proving insufficient to prevent its immediate installation as a “modern classic” – Tartt was 29 when the novel was published (Alfred A Knopf bought the rights for $450,000). The Secret History has maintained a cult following ever since: one bar in Manhattan’s East Village has even wallpapered its bathroom with pages from the book, and this aspect of the book has proven susceptible to transformation into an “aesthetic” with mass cultural appeal – the New York Times commented in 2020 on a trend on TikTok, “dark academia”, that touted styles and poses derived from a reading of Tartt’s book. Tartt had started The Secret History at Bennington, and it was whispered that her friends there had been the models for the novel’s characters – The eight years it took Donna Tartt to write The Secret History prepared fans for a lengthy wait for its follow-up, and for the most part, they were patient, content to read and reread The Secret History and share their obsession on the Tartt fansites and ‘shrines’ that sprang up in the late-1990s.

Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk – Born from Publisher Rejection

What would you do after a publisher rejects your novel for being too disturbing? Well, if you’re Chuck Palahniuk, you would write something even more disturbing and submit it. After his first novel – Invisible Monsters – was rejected by all publishers he submitted it to, he began work on his first published novel, Fight Club, writing this story in his spare time while working for Freightliner. After initially publishing it as a short story (which became chapter 6 of the novel) in the 1995 compilation Pursuit of Happiness, Palahniuk expanded it into a full novel, which, contrary to his expectations, a publisher accepted. Fight Club’s initial sales were modest, but the book found a new audience after a movie adaptation directed by David Fincher and starring Brad Pitt and Edward Norton was released in 1999. At first, the film performed not much better than its source material, polarizing critics and finding little success at the box office. The following year, however, the DVD release became a top seller, and the film’s new status as a cult favorite pumped up sales of the novel, leading to multiple reprintings. The story goes, you wrote Fight Club to disturb publishers even more because they had rejected Invisible Monsters due to its disturbing content. When they agreed to publish Fight Club, for you, was that liberating? It was a huge triumph – a gigantic accomplishment.

House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski – The Internet’s First Literary Mystery

This is a cult classic squarely rooted in the modern age — that is, it had already developed a cult following on the mysterious interwebs before its 2000 publication and subsequent print-based cult following. It’s probably too weird for mainstream consumption, and will never be read on a Kindle. And then there are those who hate it, a lot, which makes it all the cultier. Small sections of the book were downloadable off the internet before the release of the first edition, and it is said that these sections “circulated through the underbellies of Los Angeles, Las Vegas, and San Francisco, through strip clubs and recording studios, long before publication” – though very few were able to experience the book this way initially. The first edition hardback, which featured special signed inserts, was released on February 29, 2000, and Pantheon released the hardback and paperback editions simultaneously on March 7, 2000. The novel went on to win the New York Public Library’s Young Lions Fiction Award and gain a considerable cult following. Years ago, when House of Leaves was first being passed around, it was nothing more than a badly bundled heap of paper, parts of which would occasionally surface on the Internet. No one could have anticipated the small but devoted following this terrifying story would soon command. Starting with an odd assortment of marginalized youth—musicians, tattoo artists, programmers, strippers, environmentalists, and adrenaline junkies—the book eventually made its way into the hands of older generations. The novel has gone on to inspire doctorate-level courses and masters theses, cultural phenomena like the online urban legend of “the backrooms,” and incredible works of art in entirely unrealted mediums from music to video games.

The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger – From Underground Hit to High School Staple

Though it’s now a verified classic (taught in high schools and everything), Salinger’s classic started out as an underground cult hit, quickly becoming the bible for every disaffected youth in 1950s America (and at least one disturbed murderer of John Lennon). There was parental and school board outrage, articles about the “Catcher Cult,” and, by 1979, it was the most banned book of all time. Probably a good thing, too, because when you are a disaffected youth, there’s no silver bullet to something you love like parental approval. The enigma that is the 1951 novel Catcher in the Rye is so enormous it is hard to describe. The simple story of a troubled and disillusioned schoolboy, Holden Caulfield was Rebel Without a Cause before the film was ever made. A cult book should have a passionate following. Buckets of books fall into this category, including classics like J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye and On the Road by Jack Kerouac. But even megasellers Harry Potter and 50 Shades of Grey can be considered cult lit by that definition. A cult book should have the ability to alter a reader’s life or influence great change, and for the purpose of this list, it should also be a bit odd and a tad obscure. The novel accidentally became a touchstone for alienated teenagers everywhere, something Salinger never intended when he wrote about his troubled protagonist wandering through New York City.

Trainspotting by Irvine Welsh – Scotland’s Accidental Cultural Export

Published in 1993, it’s the Sex Pistol’s ‘God Save the Queen’ of modern literature. The trials and tribulations of a group of smack heads in Leith, Scotland in the 1980s soon caught on with students and aficionados of irreverent books and became a word of mouth hit. The characters of Renton, Sick Boy, Spud, Tommy and Begbie soon became ingrained in modern culture through Danny Boyle’s revolutionary and groundbreaking film of the same name. The film was released in 1997 and unconsciously rode the exploding wave of Britpop, becoming a cultural icon of its very own, sending its cast and Director on to Hollywood, and sending Irvine Welsh hurriedly to the bank for the rest of his life. If you try reading it today you’ll be surprised at how difficult to understand the slang is, and although the follow-ups, Porno and Filth fell well below the water line, Trainspotting came to help define the 90’s decade. A gritty portrayal of addiction, friendship, and survival in 1980s Edinburgh, Trainspotting is an undeniable modern cult classic. Written in a Scottish dialect, the novel follows a group of heroin addicts navigating their chaotic lives while grappling with poverty, nihilism, and fleeting moments of hope. Irvine Welsh’s vivid and uncompromising prose immerses readers in the highs and lows of addiction, offering moments of brutal honesty alongside unexpected humour and poignancy. Welsh never expected his raw, dialect-heavy novel about Edinburgh’s drug scene to become an international phenomenon that would define a generation’s relationship with British culture.

The Beach by Alex Garland – Backpacker Bible That Destroyed Paradise

In the early 1990s, backpacking in South East Asia was an expedition for those in the know and for none but the brave. The culture was virtually unheard of back in the UK, but for those who were doing it, the experiences were unforgettable. On the routes from Bali, overland through Java, Sumatra, Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand, hundreds of hedonistic and adventurous young people from every nationality in the world searched for the best party, the best grass, the best swimming, the best adventure and of course the best beach to hang out. The Khao San Road in Bangkok where Duffy gave Richard the map and killed himself became the artery to every Asian destination in the world and soon everyone wanted a piece of the action. Garland’s book exposed an amazing cultural phenomenon. And ironically, when Danny Boyle garnering his second mention on this list decimated the book with one of the worst film adaptations of all time, the backpacker phenomenon went worldwide and became what it is today. Garland’s book was a modern day Lord of The Flies and a masterpiece of modern literature. What started as a simple novel about young travelers seeking the perfect hidden beach accidentally became the handbook for an entire generation of gap-year adventurers. The book’s accidental cult status actually changed the real places it described, turning secret paradises into tourist destinations and fundamentally altering Southeast Asian backpacker culture forever.

A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess – Invented Language That Took Over

A cult classic that has inspired heated debate, stage adaptations, and an iconic Stanley Kubrick film, A Clockwork Orange remains a deeply provocative read. Written in a unique, invented slang called ‘Nadsat’, the novel follows Alex, whose gleeful lawlessness collides with the state’s oppressive efforts to ‘cure’ him through psychological conditioning. This controversial novel forces readers to question whether stripping someone of their ability to choose – even when their actions are undeniably horrific – can ever be acceptable. Burgess originally wrote the novel as a serious exploration of free will and morality, but the book’s invented Nadsat language caught on with readers in ways he never anticipated. The slang became so popular that it leaked into real-world usage, with phrases like “droog” and “horrorshow” entering youth vernacular. What was meant to be a philosophical novel about choice and conditioning accidentally became a linguistic phenomenon that influenced everything from punk rock to street slang, creating a cult following that grew beyond the author’s wildest expectations.

The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test by Tom Wolfe – New Journalism’s Accidental Masterpiece

A cult classic for its unapologetic celebration of individuality and counterculture, Tom Wolfe’s The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test is a psychedelic odyssey through the countercultural revolution of the 1960s. Chronicling the real-life escapades of Ken Kesey and his Merry Pranksters, the book captures their acid-fueled journey across America in a wildly painted bus, spreading their message of freedom, experimentation, and rebellion. Wolfe initially set out to write a straightforward piece of journalism about Ken Kesey and the emerging counterculture movement. He had no idea his immersive, stream-of-consciousness writing style would accidentally create a new form of literary journalism that would influence writers for decades. The book became a cult classic not just for its subject matter, but for the revolutionary way Wolfe told the story, using techniques borrowed from fiction to create a new hybrid form. His accidental innovation in “New Journalism” made the book essential reading for anyone interested in the 1960s counterculture, turning what was supposed to be a magazine article into one of the defining books of the era.

The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky – Teen Misfit Manual

When Pocket Books published Stephen Chbosky’s The Perks of Being a Wallflower in 1999, it introduced readers to Charlie, an introverted and traumatized teen boy different from many teens in other popular works. Because of that same connection that Whissen refers to, Charlie’s successes in the book transfer to the readers who relate. What started as Chbosky’s attempt to write a coming-of-age story accidentally became the ultimate handbook for misunderstood teenagers everywhere. The book’s epistolary format, told through Charlie’s letters to an unnamed friend, created an intimacy that readers found irresistible. Chbosky never expected his quiet novel about mental health, sexuality, and growing up to become such a phenomenon among young people who saw themselves in Charlie’s struggles. The book’s accidental cult status grew through word-of-mouth recommendations between teenagers who passed it around like a secret, creating a devoted following that persisted long before social media amplified its reach. The novel’s honest portrayal of issues like abuse, homosexuality, and mental illness resonated with readers in ways that surprised even its author.

Geek Love by Katherine Dunn – Circus Freaks as Literary Art

Katherine Dunn’s Geek Love centers on a family of circus performers, mutated by experiments involving drugs, insecticides and other nasty chemicals. Writing about the cult fiction classic on Wired, Caitlin Roper explains the pull as being about “the idea of a character’s strangeness as the source of her strength…the Fabulon freaks are all misfits, each with a singular skill. As a kid, I wanted to have some special power. I wanted to be like everyone else, but also, somehow, secretly special and indomitable.” Whissen suggests that by bonding the character and the reader, the stories reinforce that it is good to experience the world in a less mainstream way. Dunn’s bizarre novel about a family that deliberately creates “freak” children for their traveling circus was initially dismissed by many as too strange and grotesque for mainstream audiences. Publishers were hesitant, and early reviews were mixed. However, the book accidentally found its perfect audience among readers who felt like outsiders themselves. The novel’s celebration of difference and its unflinching examination of what makes us human resonated with people who had always felt like misfits. Word-of-mouth spread among alternative communities, and the book slowly built a devoted cult following that appreciated its dark humor and profound themes about identity, family, and belonging.

The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt – Prize Winner Turned Guilty Pleasure

When Donna Tartt’s The Goldfinch won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 2014, it seemed destined for literary respectability rather than cult status. The 771-page novel about a boy whose life is changed by a terrorist attack at an art museum was praised by critics but also sparked intense debate about its literary merit. Some dismissed it as overly long and sentimental, while others hailed it as a masterpiece. This divisive reception accidentally created a cult following among readers who felt they had to defend their love for the book. The novel’s detailed exploration of art, loss, and coming-of-age resonated with readers who found themselves returning to it repeatedly, despite its intimidating length. Book clubs embraced it, and online communities formed around discussions of its themes and symbolism. What was meant to be a serious literary novel accidentally became a comfort read for many, with fans treating it almost like a guilty pleasure they had to justify to more “serious” readers.

Speedboat by Renata Adler – Experimental Fiction’s Hidden Gem

Renata Adler was a formidable critical and literary figure in the ’60s and ’70s, with the kind of obstinate, intellectual-badass reputation that delights some and faintly terrifies others. Her self-constructed fall from grace, at least with the critical world, is well known, but she is cherished more for her first novel, Speedboat, a non-linear, delicious wisp of a thing, which immediately became a cult classic among writers and lovers of experimental literature. As Michael Robbins of the Chicago Tribune described it, the book is “the kind you buy multiple copies of

Share this post on: