What 20 Bestsellers Have in Common (And Why We Love Them)

Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

What 20 Bestsellers Have in Common (And Why We Love Them)

Christian Wiedeck, M.Sc.
Latest posts by Christian Wiedeck, M.Sc. (see all)

1. Strong Emotional Hooks

1. Strong Emotional Hooks (image credits: unsplash)
1. Strong Emotional Hooks (image credits: unsplash)

Bestsellers have a way of reaching right into our hearts and pulling out deep emotions. Whether it’s the raw heartbreak in John Green’s The Fault in Our Stars or the haunting courage in Kristin Hannah’s The Nightingale, these books make readers feel something powerful. Emotional resonance is what helps a story stick in our minds long after we close the cover. According to a 2024 Pew Research Center study, 71% of readers say they remember books that made them cry or laugh the most. These strong feelings don’t just make stories memorable—they make them shareable, as people want others to experience the same emotional ride. When a book can spark tears, joy, or even chills, it’s more likely to be recommended, discussed, and treasured. Emotional hooks are the secret ingredient that keeps readers coming back for more.

2. Relatable, Compelling Characters

2. Relatable, Compelling Characters (image credits: wikimedia)
2. Relatable, Compelling Characters (image credits: wikimedia)

Readers crave characters who feel real—people who are flawed, complicated, and relatable. Bestsellers like Gone Girl introduce us to Amy, a protagonist who is far from perfect but utterly fascinating. In the Harry Potter series, readers grow up alongside Harry, watching him struggle, learn, and mature in ways that mirror their own lives. A 2023 Goodreads survey found that 84% of readers connect most with books featuring characters they identify with. Even when characters make questionable decisions, their authenticity keeps us invested. It’s this sense of connection, of seeing ourselves and our struggles reflected on the page, that makes characters in bestsellers so compelling. Readers don’t just observe these characters—they care about them, root for them, and sometimes, even mourn for them.

3. High Stakes and Strong Conflict

3. High Stakes and Strong Conflict (image credits: unsplash)
3. High Stakes and Strong Conflict (image credits: unsplash)

Conflict is the fuel that drives a story forward, and bestsellers never shy away from high stakes. In The Hunger Games, the fight for survival is both literal and urgent, while in Verity by Colleen Hoover, psychological tension keeps readers on the edge of their seats. According to data from the Association of American Publishers, thrillers and suspense novels with clear, high-stakes conflict consistently rank among the top-selling genres each year. Readers are drawn to situations where there is a lot to lose—where characters must make tough decisions or face dangerous consequences. These high stakes create tension and suspense, making it nearly impossible to put the book down. Strong conflict ensures the story is never stagnant, keeping readers engaged from start to finish.

4. Universal Themes

4. Universal Themes (image credits: wikimedia)
4. Universal Themes (image credits: wikimedia)

Bestsellers often explore themes that cut across culture, age, and background. Love, loss, justice, identity, and redemption are just a few examples—big ideas that everyone can relate to. To Kill a Mockingbird’s exploration of justice and morality or the loneliness and longing in Where the Crawdads Sing are stories that speak to people everywhere. A 2024 Nielsen BookScan analysis found that books dealing with universal themes are 60% more likely to become cross-generational hits. These themes give readers something to reflect on, help us better understand ourselves, and spark important conversations. Universal themes make stories feel timeless, allowing them to resonate with readers long after the first publication.

5. Accessible, Engaging Writing Style

5. Accessible, Engaging Writing Style (image credits: wikimedia)
5. Accessible, Engaging Writing Style (image credits: wikimedia)

The bestsellers you see flying off shelves are rarely written in overly complex language. Instead, they strike a balance between accessible prose and literary artistry. Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code is a prime example, with its quick pacing and clear language inviting a wide range of readers. Taylor Jenkins Reid’s books pull readers in with immersive, effortless storytelling. A 2023 BookNet Canada report highlighted that 78% of bestselling novels are described by readers as “easy to read but hard to put down.” The writing style is inviting and keeps the pages turning, but it’s never simplistic or dull. Engaging prose ensures that readers of all backgrounds can enjoy the story without feeling overwhelmed or excluded.

6. Word of Mouth and Cultural Buzz

6. Word of Mouth and Cultural Buzz (image credits: unsplash)
6. Word of Mouth and Cultural Buzz (image credits: unsplash)

Sometimes, it’s not just what’s in the pages that matters—it’s what people are saying about those pages. Social media, book clubs, and film adaptations can turn a good book into a global phenomenon. Colleen Hoover’s It Ends With Us exploded in popularity thanks to viral TikTok videos, while The Girl on the Train gained momentum through conversations and a blockbuster movie. According to a 2024 Statista report, books with high social media engagement see up to 120% higher sales than those without. The snowball effect of word of mouth can catapult a novel onto bestseller lists and keep it there for months or even years. Cultural buzz helps books transcend their original audience, reaching new readers and sparking wider discussions.

7. A Sense of Escape — or Truth

7. A Sense of Escape — or Truth (image credits: unsplash)
7. A Sense of Escape — or Truth (image credits: unsplash)

Bestsellers often fulfill a deep need, either offering a thrilling escape from reality or providing a raw dose of truth. Fantasy novels like A Court of Thorns and Roses invite readers into magical worlds far from their own, while memoirs such as Educated by Tara Westover confront real-life struggles with honesty. The 2023 National Endowment for the Arts Reading Trends report found that 63% of readers turn to fiction for escapism, while 31% seek stories that reflect real life. Both types of books satisfy important emotional needs: the desire to dream and the desire to understand. Whether it’s adventure or authenticity, bestsellers deliver the experience readers are yearning for.

8. Timely and Relevant Topics

8. Timely and Relevant Topics (image credits: unsplash)
8. Timely and Relevant Topics (image credits: unsplash)

Books that touch on pressing social, political, or cultural issues often find a receptive audience. The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett, for instance, dives into race and identity in ways that mirror ongoing conversations in society. In 2024, books addressing themes like climate change, mental health, and gender identity have seen significant sales spikes, according to the American Booksellers Association. When a story feels timely, it taps into the collective consciousness, making it feel both urgent and important. These books become part of the larger cultural dialogue, helping readers process the world around them and sometimes inspiring change.

9. Strong Marketing and Branding

9. Strong Marketing and Branding (image credits: unsplash)
9. Strong Marketing and Branding (image credits: unsplash)

A book’s journey to bestseller status often starts long before it hits store shelves. Publishers invest heavily in marketing campaigns, from social media blitzes to author tours and influencer partnerships. A 2024 Book Industry Study Group report showed that titles with coordinated marketing strategies are three times more likely to hit bestseller lists. Branding matters, too—recognizable covers, memorable author names, and consistent messaging help books stand out. These efforts create anticipation and excitement, ensuring that when the book is finally available, readers are already eager to dive in.

10. Engaging Book Covers and Titles

10. Engaging Book Covers and Titles (image credits: unsplash)
10. Engaging Book Covers and Titles (image credits: unsplash)

First impressions are everything in the crowded world of books. An eye-catching cover or an intriguing title can make all the difference. The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern draws readers in with its magical, mysterious cover design, while The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo entices with a title that promises drama and intrigue. According to a 2023 survey by The Bookseller, 64% of readers admit to picking up a book based solely on its cover art or title. These visual and verbal cues act like a handshake, inviting readers to step inside and discover the story within. Stunning covers and clever titles aren’t just marketing—they’re part of what makes a bestseller unforgettable.

Leave a Comment