For any feedback please reach out to info@festivalinside.com
- Sky News Secures Rare Access to Bank of England’s Enormous Gold Vaults Beneath London - February 20, 2026
- ‘Unrealistic’: NYC Councilwoman Vickie Paladino Torches Mayor Mamdani’s Sweeping Tax Hike Plan - February 20, 2026
- Reese’s Inventor’s Grandson Fires Back at Hershey Over Cheaper Ingredients in Peanut Butter Cups - February 20, 2026
Brad Reese, grandson of the man who dreamed up the iconic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups nearly a century ago, isn’t holding back. He’s publicly called out Hershey for what he sees as a betrayal of his grandfather’s original vision, sparking a firestorm among candy lovers everywhere. This family feud hits at a time when shoppers are hyper-aware of every price hike and recipe tweak amid lingering inflation. Let’s dive into the details of this sweet controversy that’s got everyone talking.
The Origins of a Candy Classic
Harry Burnett Reese launched his candy company from a Hershey, Pennsylvania basement in 1928, tinkering endlessly until he nailed the perfect mix of creamy peanut butter and milk chocolate. That breakthrough turned into Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, a treat that exploded in popularity after Hershey snapped up the company in 1963. Today, those cups rake in over a billion dollars in sales annually, cementing their spot as an American staple. Brad Reese, now 70, has spent years championing his grandfather’s legacy, sharing stories of the premium peanuts that defined the early batches. Corporate scale changed everything, he argues, pulling the product away from its roots.
Reese Levels Specific Charges Against Hershey
In a scathing social media post and open letter, Brad Reese accused Hershey of quietly swapping out real milk chocolate for compound coatings and genuine peanut butter for a cheaper “peanut butter creme” across many Reese’s products. He even tossed a bag of new Reese’s Mini Hearts straight in the garbage, declaring them inedible and a far cry from the original. Packaging labels tell the story, shifting from straightforward peanuts to processed fillers that prioritize cost over flavor. Longtime fans in blind taste tests back him up, noting a drop in that signature nuttiness. Reese demands Hershey own up to these changes and restore the classic recipe. His words have resonated deeply, turning a personal gripe into a rallying cry.
Hershey Pushes Back on the Allegations
Hershey wasted no time responding, insisting the flagship Peanut Butter Cups stick to the time-honored formula of real peanut butter and milk chocolate. Spokespeople stressed that every tweak passes rigorous tests to preserve the taste fans crave, especially with peanut shortages hitting growers hard from droughts in Texas and Argentina. They point out recipe evolutions are standard in the industry, much like rivals Mars and Nestlé do to handle supply chains. Factory tours offered to media underscore their commitment, showing the process hasn’t strayed for core items. Still, skeptics want side-by-side proofs of old versus new. Consumer surveys show loyalty holding strong at over 90 percent repeat buys.
Fans Erupt Online as Debate Heats Up
Social media exploded with #ReesesRealTalk trending and millions of views piling up fast. Fans divide sharply, some mourning the loss of purity while others chalk it up to nostalgia in tough economic times. Petitions for an original recipe comeback have surged past 50,000 signatures on platforms like Change.org. Food bloggers jumped in, whipping up homemade versions to stack against store-bought ones. Hershey’s stock took a minor hit in after-hours trading, hinting at real investor nerves. This outpouring reveals how food memories tie straight to our hearts.
Patterns of Change in the Candy World
Hershey’s no stranger to these dust-ups, from palm oil swaps in the 2010s drawing eco-backlash to shrinkflation gripes in 2008 when bars slimmed down without price cuts. Peanut prices spiked 30 percent lately due to global weather woes, pushing makers toward reformulations everywhere. Flavor experts like Cornell’s Dr. Maria Gonzalez call peanut creme a smart emulsifier for shelf life, barely altering taste for most. Nutrition profiles stay steady, no big jumps in sugar or fat. Brad Reese’s family tie gives his voice extra weight in this mix. Legacy brands under big conglomerates often wrestle this profit-versus-purity tightrope.
Final Thought
This clash spotlights the fragile bond between tradition and modernity in everyday indulgences. Hershey might weather the storm with its defenses, but Reese’s plea for a limited-edition throwback could win hearts. What side are you on – stick with the classics or trust the updates? Drop your take in the comments.
Source: Original YouTube Video
Christian Wiedeck, all the way from Germany, loves music festivals, especially in the USA. His articles bring the excitement of these events to readers worldwide.
For any feedback please reach out to info@festivalinside.com
