11 Underrated Bands That Time Forgot—but Shouldn’t Have

Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

11 Underrated Bands That Time Forgot—but Shouldn’t Have

Luca von Burkersroda

Big Star

Big Star (image credits: wikimedia)
Big Star (image credits: wikimedia)

Big Star’s story reads like a heartbreaking novel—brimming with talent and timeless songs, yet dogged by bad luck and mismanagement. Formed in Memphis in 1971, the band’s crisp, jangly sound laid the foundation for what would later be called alternative and power pop. Their debut, “#1 Record,” blended shimmering guitars and bittersweet lyrics, but only sold about 10,000 copies due to distribution issues. Despite the commercial flop, Big Star’s tracks like “Thirteen” and “September Gurls” quietly inspired entire generations of musicians. By the 1990s, critics were calling them “the greatest band you’ve never heard of,” and bands such as R.E.M. and The Replacements openly championed their influence. Today, their legacy endures, and their albums are now considered classics, making their initial neglect even more shocking. The band’s tale is a reminder that brilliance isn’t always rewarded right away.

The Zombies

The Zombies (image credits: wikimedia)
The Zombies (image credits: wikimedia)

The Zombies are often remembered for the hauntingly beautiful “Time of the Season,” but their true genius runs far deeper. In the 1960s, their lush, baroque-pop sound set them apart from the British Invasion crowd, yet their album “Odessey and Oracle” was initially dismissed, barely cracking the charts. Critics now routinely list the album among the best of all time, with Rolling Stone placing it high in its “500 Greatest Albums” list. The Zombies’ ornate harmonies and intricate arrangements predated the psychedelic movement, yet recognition came decades late, especially in the U.S. Surviving members have seen a revival of interest in their music, with sold-out reunion tours and their 2019 induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. The emotional depth and musical sophistication of The Zombies remain a hidden treasure for anyone willing to dig deeper than their biggest hit.

Love

Love (image credits: wikimedia)
Love (image credits: wikimedia)

Love’s psychedelic masterpiece “Forever Changes” was released in 1967 to little fanfare, but its influence has only grown with time. The band, led by enigmatic frontman Arthur Lee, wove orchestral flourishes and folk-rock melodies into haunting, prophetic lyrics. Despite its now-legendary status, the album barely made a dent commercially, peaking at number 154 on the Billboard charts. Over the years, musicians from The Doors to The Stone Roses have cited Love as a crucial influence, and “Forever Changes” frequently appears in lists of the greatest albums ever made. The album’s enduring appeal lies in its unique blend of genres and Lee’s poetic vision, which critics now describe as one of the most powerful statements of the 1960s. Love’s inability to achieve lasting fame during their active years only adds to the sense of mystery and injustice surrounding their story.

Television

Television (image credits: wikimedia)
Television (image credits: wikimedia)

Television’s “Marquee Moon” is often praised as a cornerstone of punk and art rock, but the band’s commercial fortunes never matched their critical acclaim. Emerging from New York’s legendary CBGB scene in the mid-1970s, Television’s sound was marked by dazzling, interlocking guitars and poetic lyrics. The album barely cracked the top 30 in the UK and failed to chart in the U.S., yet its reputation has only grown with time. Modern acts like The Strokes and Sonic Youth have cited Television’s influence, and “Marquee Moon” regularly features in critics’ “best of all time” lists. Despite their short run and modest sales, Television’s impact on guitar-driven music is undeniable. Their legacy is a reminder that some of the most innovative bands never get the mainstream attention they deserve.

The Replacements

The Replacements (image credits: wikimedia)
The Replacements (image credits: wikimedia)

The Replacements stormed out of Minneapolis in the early 1980s, bringing a reckless, emotionally charged sound that bridged punk and college rock. Their 1984 album “Let It Be” is now considered a genre-defining classic, featuring songs that veered between heartbreak and hilarity. Yet, their reputation for chaotic live shows and an unwillingness to compromise meant they never broke into the mainstream. Albums like “Tim” and “Pleased to Meet Me” are hailed as blueprints for alternative rock, influencing giants like Nirvana and Green Day, who have both praised the band’s raw authenticity. Despite their cult status and critical adulation, Top 40 radio never embraced them. The Replacements’ journey is proof that a band’s true value isn’t always reflected in record sales or awards.

Can

Can (image credits: wikimedia)
Can (image credits: wikimedia)

German experimental rock band Can pushed musical boundaries farther than most, yet mainstream recognition always eluded them. Formed in the late 1960s, Can’s albums like “Tago Mago” and “Ege Bamyasi” were wild blends of rock, jazz, and avant-garde experimentation. Their hypnotic rhythms and improvisational jams became the blueprint for later genres like post-punk, ambient, and even hip-hop—Kanye West famously sampled Can’s “Vitamin C” on his 2013 album “Yeezus.” Despite this far-reaching influence, Can’s albums rarely charted outside Germany, and their music was often considered too strange for radio. Today, artists from Radiohead to LCD Soundsystem cite Can as a major inspiration. Their story is a testament to how groundbreaking art can remain hidden in plain sight.

The Go-Betweens

The Go-Betweens (image credits: wikimedia)
The Go-Betweens (image credits: wikimedia)

Australian band The Go-Betweens crafted literate, melancholic pop songs that never quite found the audience they deserved. Formed in Brisbane in 1977, their music was characterized by clever lyrics and a gentle, jangly sound, especially on albums like “16 Lovers Lane.” Despite critical acclaim—Pitchfork called them “one of the best bands of the 1980s”—they struggled to break through commercially, with most of their singles failing to chart outside Australia. The band’s intricate, heartfelt songwriting influenced acts like Belle and Sebastian and The National, who have both publicly acknowledged their debt to The Go-Betweens. Their bittersweet legacy is one of music’s great what-ifs, as their catalog remains a hidden gem for those willing to seek it out.

Galaxie 500

Galaxie 500 (image credits: wikimedia)
Galaxie 500 (image credits: wikimedia)

Galaxie 500’s dreamy, minimalist sound paved the way for entire genres, but during their brief existence, they remained on the fringes of indie music. Formed in Boston in the late 1980s, their records “Today,” “On Fire,” and “This Is Our Music” offered a hypnotic, slowcore approach that was a stark contrast to the era’s noisy grunge and punk scenes. Their lack of commercial success belied their influence—modern bands like Beach House and Low have cited Galaxie 500 as a key inspiration. The band’s ethereal melodies and introspective lyrics evoke nostalgia and longing, creating a sound that still resonates with new listeners. Even though they never reached the charts, their music endures as a quiet force in the background of indie history.

Hüsker Dü

Hüsker Dü (image credits: wikimedia)
Hüsker Dü (image credits: wikimedia)

Hüsker Dü’s role in transforming hardcore punk into melodic alternative rock is often overshadowed by the massive acts they inspired. Hailing from Minnesota, the band released landmark albums like “Zen Arcade” (1984), which blurred the lines between punk, pop, and psychedelia. Despite their profound influence—bands like Nirvana, Foo Fighters, and Pixies have all cited Hüsker Dü—their records didn’t translate into mainstream hits, with their best-selling album never breaking into the Billboard 200’s top 100. Their raw, emotionally intense songs and relentless touring built a loyal underground following, but they never achieved the fame of their peers. Hüsker Dü’s legacy is a powerful reminder that some of the most important innovations in music happen out of the spotlight.

Felt

Felt (image credits: unsplash)
Felt (image credits: unsplash)

Felt, a British post-punk band formed in the early 1980s, is often described as one of music’s best-kept secrets. Their jangly guitars and poetic lyrics, especially on albums like “Forever Breathes the Lonely Word,” created a unique atmosphere that was both romantic and melancholic. Despite glowing reviews from the likes of NME and Melody Maker, Felt never made a dent in the charts, and their albums were often hard to find outside the UK. Bands such as The Smiths and Belle and Sebastian have acknowledged Felt’s influence on their own melodic style. Over time, collectors and indie fans have rediscovered Felt’s back catalog, cementing their reputation as unheralded pioneers. Their music remains a beautiful secret waiting to be discovered by new generations.

The Sound

The Sound (image credits: unsplash)
The Sound (image credits: unsplash)

The Sound, contemporaries of Joy Division, carved out a sound equally haunting and urgent, yet their commercial fortunes never matched their talent. Led by Adrian Borland, the band’s 1981 album “From the Lion’s Mouth” is now regarded as a post-punk classic, filled with emotionally charged lyrics and atmospheric guitars. Despite glowing reviews in both UK and European music press, The Sound struggled to gain wider attention, with their releases often overshadowed by more commercially successful acts. Modern bands like Interpol and Editors have acknowledged the band’s influence, borrowing from their brooding style and intensity. The Sound’s music continues to resonate with listeners seeking depth and honesty in their post-punk playlists. Their story stands as a poignant example of how even the most powerful voices can be lost in the noise.

Leave a Comment